- The Waismann technique
On July 24, members of Lismore Base Hospital's departments of
anaesthesia, general practice, intensive care and medical
administration met with Dr Andre Waismann of the CITA-Israel
Institute from Tel Aviv, Israel.
Dr Waismann was brought to Australia following the media publicity
concerning the treatment in his clinic of a North Coast heroin
addict. The woman, an addict for some 18 months, had developed the
usual sequela of the addiction - physically, morally and socially.
She had sought help from me as her family doctor, several of my
partners and through us, the psychiatric, and drug and alcohol
rehabilitation services. The whole situation was on a progressive
downward spiral. She said she knew she ought to give up heroin, but
couldn't; the hold was far too strong. Finally, in desperation, she
attended Dr Waismann's clinic for one day, and was away from
Australia for one week. She is now off heroin and has a full-time
job.
Dr Waismann's technique, known as Rapid Opiate Detoxification, or
Opiate Receptor Neuroregulation, involves keeping a patient in an
intensive care unit for four to six hours. During this time they are
intubated to protect their airway and given the opiate antagonist
Naltrexone via an orogastric tube.
Dr Waismann's theory is that the opiate receptors responsible for
the craving are totally blocked during this time and are kept blocked
by oral Naltrexone taken once a day for the following 12 months,
during which time the receptors progressively atrophy.
Dr Waismann claimed he had successfully detoxified 3000 heroin
addicts and that at the 18 month follow-up, 80 per cent were still
off heroin and 40 per cent were back in full time employment. The
percentage involved with crime was also dramatically reduced.
In response to questions as to why no double-blind trials have
been performed, Dr Waismann maintained that the results were so
obvious this would not be ethical. He also said that as a private
clinic, he did not have the time to do the required research for
publication, but that he would be happy to send the preliminary
follow up papers done by another group on his patients. This was
requested by the group.
In response to a question as to why Naltrexone worked in the
long-term on his patients and not on others (Naltraxone has been
available for 20 years), Dr Waismann said the difference was that the
receptors required total blocking to suppress the craving before the
maintenance Naltraxone was successful in preventing the recurrence of
the craving. He also said that drug counselling, rather than
lifestyle counselling, helped to stimulate the craving.
At the end of our quite frank discussion with Dr Waismann, all
were interested and the numbers who thought it should be further
looked into outnumbered the cynics.
What we do know for certain is that a young woman who wasn't able
to be helped by our best endeavours locally, was very much helped by
Dr Waismann's technique. At this stage we need further evidence that
the proven results from this one case can be extrapolated to a
significant number of other heroin addicts.
Dr Waismann himself seemed only too willing to show and teach
others his technique for the treatment of heroin addiction which he
regards as a medical problem that should be treated medically and not
psychologically.
Dr Paul Earner
Alstonville NSW Australia 2477
|